Thanks in large part to the non-partisan efforts and cooperation across the aisle by the Liberal and Conservative Co-Chairs of the all-party Parliamentary Outdoor Caucus (Members of Parliament Yvonne Jones and Bob Zimmer), a major legislative threat to the future of fishing was dealt a stunning defeat on Wednesday, October 5 in the House of Commons. MP Blaine Calkins chairs the Conservative Hunting & Angling Caucus and also worked to educate his fellow MPs on the issue. By a vote of 198 to 84, Conservative and Liberal MPs stood together with Cabinet and Prime Minister Trudeau in support of our outdoor heritage activities and defeated a Bill which would have made it a federal crime to kill a fish or shoot a duck for dinner.
The Modernizing Animal Protections Act (C-246) was introduced in Parliament on February 26, 2016 by MP Nathanial Erskine-Smith (L-Beaches-East York) with the full support of U.S. and Canadian based organizations dedicated to ending all fishing, hunting, trapping, agriculture and medical research where animals are involved. Although the Bill was promoted as necessary to ban shark finning (which is already illegal) and to stop the alleged use of dog and cat fur in garments – the true purpose was far more sinister.
No fewer than seven previous Bills with identical language and substantial fines and jail time for anyone killing an animal ‘brutally or viciously’ (even if the animal dies immediately), were repeatedly introduced in Parliament since 1999. Of course it is no coincidence the animal rights organizations promoting this legislation have a long history attempting to portray fishing, hunting and trapping to unsuspecting urbanites and media as being fundamentally brutal and vicious. For people who have never been fishing or hunting and have no first-hand knowledge of these activities, these deceptive ad campaigns come across as being believable.
CSIA worked closely with the Ontario Federation of Anglers & Hunters to inform MPs from all parties about the Trojan Horse agenda contained in C-246. Simply by letting the evidence speak for itself, the true threats which were contained in the Bill, but not revealed by MP Erskine-Smith, convinced Liberal and Conservative MPs alike that the millions of Canadians who enjoy fishing and hunting do so responsibly, humanely and should not face the threat of a criminal charge for participating in our great outdoor traditions.
To those MPs from both parties who voted against C-246, we offer our sincere thanks. To those who voted for C-246 and in favor of imposing criminal charges for people who enjoy fishing, we urge you to spend a day on the water to learn first-hand what all anglers already know – fish are fun to catch and healthy to eat.
How your MP voted on this important legislation appears below. Take the time to contact them through the Keep Canada Fishing website interactive feature, and let them know what you think about their vote. After all, the future of fishing is in your hands.
You can view more on the official Parliament of Canada website, here and at openparliament.ca.
Bloc
- Yes Xavier Barsalou-Duval
- Yes Mario Beaulieu
- Yes Michel Boudrias
- Yes Rhéal Fortin
- Yes Marilène Gill
- No Simon Marcil
- Yes Monique Pauzé
- Didn’t vote Louis Plamondon
- Didn’t vote Gabriel Ste-Marie
- Yes Luc Thériault
Conservative
- Didn’t vote Ziad Aboultaif
- No Dan Albas
- No Harold Albrecht
- No Dean Allison
- Didn’t vote Rona Ambrose
- No David Anderson
- No Mel Arnold
- Didn’t vote John Barlow
- No Candice Bergen
- No Maxime Bernier
- No Luc Berthold
- No James Bezan
- No Steven Blaney
- No Kelly Block
- No Sylvie Boucher
- No John Brassard
- No Gord Brown
- No Blaine Calkins
- No Colin Carrie
- No Michael Chong
- No Alupa Clarke
- Didn’t vote Tony Clement
- No Michael Cooper
- No Gérard Deltell
- No Kerry Diotte
- No Todd Doherty
- No Earl Dreeshen
- No Jim Eglinski
- No Ted Falk
- No Ed Fast
- No Diane Finley
- No Cheryl Gallant
- No Bernard Généreux
- No Garnett Genuis
- No Marilyn Gladu
- Didn’t vote Joël Godin
- No Jacques Gourde
- No Rachael Harder
- No Randy Hoback
- No Matt Jeneroux
- No Pat Kelly
- Didn’t vote Jason Kenney
- No Peter Kent
- No Robert Gordon Kitchen
- Didn’t vote Tom Kmiec
- No Mike Lake
- No Guy Lauzon
- No Denis Lebel
- No Kellie Leitch
- Didn’t vote Ron Liepert
- No Ben Lobb
- Didn’t vote Tom Lukiwski
- No Dave MacKenzie
- No Larry Maguire
- Didn’t vote Kelly McCauley
- No Phil McColeman
- No Cathy McLeod
- No Larry Miller
- Didn’t vote John Nater
- No Rob Nicholson
- Didn’t vote Alex Nuttall
- Didn’t vote Deepak Obhrai
- No Erin O’Toole
- No Pierre Paul-Hus
- No Pierre Poilievre
- No Lisa Raitt
- Didn’t vote Alain Rayes
- Didn’t vote Scott Reid
- Yes Michelle Rempel
- Didn’t vote Blake Richards
- No Gerry Ritz
- No Bob Saroya
- No Andrew Scheer
- No Jamie Schmale
- No Martin Shields
- No Bev Shipley
- No Robert Sopuck
- No Kevin Sorenson
- No Bruce Stanton
- No Mark Strahl
- No Shannon Stubbs
- No David Sweet
- No David Tilson
- No Bradley Trost
- No Dave Van Kesteren
- No Peter Van Loan
- No Karen Vecchio
- No Arnold Viersen
- No Cathay Wagantall
- No Mark Warawa
- No Chris Warkentin
- Didn’t vote Dianne Lynn Watts
- No Kevin Waugh
- Yes Len Webber
- No Alice Wong
- No David Yurdiga
- No Bob Zimmer
Green
- Didn’t vote Elizabeth May
Independent
Liberal
- Didn’t vote John Aldag
- No Omar Alghabra
- No Leona Alleslev
- Yes William Amos
- Yes Gary Anandasangaree
- No René Arseneault
- No Chandra Arya
- Didn’t vote Ramez Ayoub
- Yes Vance Badawey
- No Larry Bagnell
- No Navdeep Bains
- Yes Frank Baylis
- Yes Terry Beech
- No Carolyn Bennett
- No Marie-Claude Bibeau
- Yes Chris Bittle
- No Bill Blair
- No Randy Boissonnault
- No Mike Bossio
- No Bob Bratina
- No Pierre Breton
- No Scott Brison
- No Celina Caesar-Chavannes
- No Jim Carr
- Didn’t vote Bill Casey
- Didn’t vote Sean Casey
- No Bardish Chagger
- No François-Philippe Champagne
- No Arnold Chan
- No Shaun Chen
- No Serge Cormier
- No Rodger Cuzner
- Yes Julie Dabrusin
- Yes Pam Damoff
- Didn’t vote Matt DeCourcey
- No Sukh Dhaliwal
- No Anju Dhillon
- No Nicola Di Iorio
- No Stéphane Dion
- No Francis Drouin
- No Emmanuel Dubourg
- No Jean-Yves Duclos
- No Terry Duguid
- No Kirsty Duncan
- Yes Julie Dzerowicz
- Didn’t vote Wayne Easter
- Yes Ali Ehsassi
- No Fayçal El-Khoury
- Yes Neil Ellis
- Yes Nathaniel Erskine-Smith
- No Mark Eyking
- Yes Doug Eyolfson
- Yes Greg Fergus
- No Andy Fillmore
- No Pat Finnigan
- No Darren Fisher
- No Peter Fonseca
- No Judy Foote
- No Peter Fragiskatos
- No Sean Fraser
- No Colin Fraser
- Didn’t vote Chrystia Freeland
- Yes Hedy Fry
- Yes Stephen Fuhr
- No Marc Garneau
- Yes Mark Gerretsen
- No Pam Goldsmith-Jones
- No Ralph Goodale
- Yes Karina Gould
- No David Graham
- Didn’t vote Raj Grewal
- No Patty Hajdu
- Yes Ken Hardie
- No TJ Harvey
- No Kent Hehr
- Yes Mark Holland
- No Anthony Housefather
- Yes Ahmed Hussen
- No Gudie Hutchings
- No Angelo Iacono
- No Mélanie Joly
- Didn’t vote Yvonne Jones
- No Bernadette Jordan
- Didn’t vote Majid Jowhari
- No Darshan Singh Kang
- No Iqra Khalid
- No Kamal Khera
- Yes David Lametti
- No Kevin Lamoureux
- No Linda Lapointe
- No Stéphane Lauzon
- Didn’t vote Dominic LeBlanc
- No Diane Lebouthillier
- No Paul Lefebvre
- No Denis Lemieux
- No Andrew Leslie
- Didn’t vote Michael Levitt
- Yes Joël Lightbound
- No Alaina Lockhart
- No Wayne Long
- No Lloyd Longfield
- No Karen Ludwig
- No Lawrence MacAulay
- Didn’t vote Steven MacKinnon
- Yes James Maloney
- No Rémi Massé
- Yes Bryan May
- No John McCallum
- No Karen McCrimmon
- No Ken McDonald
- No David McGuinty
- Yes John McKay
- No Catherine McKenna
- Yes Ron McKinnon
- No Michael McLeod
- Yes Alexandra Mendes
- No Marco Mendicino
- No MaryAnn Mihychuk
- No Marc Miller
- No Maryam Monsef
- Didn’t vote Bill Morneau
- No Bobby Morrissey
- No Joyce Murray
- No Eva Nassif
- No Bob Nault
- Didn’t vote Jennifer O’Connell
- Yes Rob Oliphant
- Yes John Oliver
- No Seamus O’Regan
- Yes Robert-Falcon Ouellette
- Yes Denis Paradis
- Didn’t vote Joe Peschisolido
- Didn’t vote Kyle Peterson
- No Ginette Petitpas Taylor
- No Jane Philpott
- No Michel Picard
- No Jean-Claude Poissant
- No Carla Qualtrough
- Didn’t vote Yasmin Ratansi
- Didn’t vote Geoff Regan
- No Jean Rioux
- No Yves Robillard
- No Pablo Rodriguez
- Didn’t vote Sherry Romanado
- No Anthony Rota
- Didn’t vote Kim Rudd
- Yes Dan Ruimy
- No Don Rusnak
- Didn’t vote Ruby Sahota
- No Raj Saini
- No Harjit S. Sajjan
- No Darrell Samson
- No Ramesh Sangha
- No Randeep Sarai
- Didn’t vote Francis Scarpaleggia
- Yes Peter Schiefke
- Yes Deb Schulte
- No Marc Serré
- No Judy Sgro
- No Brenda Shanahan
- No Terry Sheehan
- No Sonia Sidhu
- No Jati Sidhu
- Yes Gagan Sikand
- No Scott Simms
- No Amarjeet Sohi
- No Francesco Sorbara
- No Sven Spengemann
- Yes Marwan Tabbara
- No Geng Tan
- No Filomena Tassi
- No Justin Trudeau
- Yes Dan Vandal
- No Anita Vandenbeld
- No Adam Vaughan
- Yes Arif Virani
- Didn’t vote Nick Whalen
- Didn’t vote Jonathan Wilkinson
- No Jody Wilson-Raybould
- Didn’t vote Borys Wrzesnewskyj
- No Kate Young
- No Salma Zahid
NDP
- Yes Charlie Angus
- Yes Niki Ashton
- Yes Robert Aubin
- Yes Sheri Benson
- Didn’t vote Daniel Blaikie
- Yes Rachel Blaney
- Yes Alexandre Boulerice
- Yes Marjolaine Boutin-Sweet
- Yes Ruth Ellen Brosseau
- Yes Richard Cannings
- Yes Guy Caron
- Yes François Choquette
- Yes David Christopherson
- Didn’t vote Nathan Cullen
- Yes Don Davies
- Yes Fin Donnelly
- Yes Matthew Dubé
- Yes Linda Duncan
- Yes Pierre-Luc Dusseault
- Didn’t vote Scott Duvall
- Yes Randall Garrison
- Yes Cheryl Hardcastle
- Didn’t vote Carol Hughes
- Yes Gord Johns
- Didn’t vote Georgina Jolibois
- Yes Peter Julian
- Yes Jenny Kwan
- Yes Hélène Laverdière
- Didn’t vote Alistair MacGregor
- Yes Sheila Malcolmson
- Yes Brian Masse
- Yes Irene Mathyssen
- Yes Christine Moore
- Yes Thomas Mulcair
- Yes Pierre Nantel
- Yes Anne Minh-Thu Quach
- Yes Tracey Ramsey
- Yes Murray Rankin
- Yes Romeo Saganash
- Yes Brigitte Sansoucy
- No Wayne Stetski
- Yes Kennedy Stewart
- Yes Karine Trudel
- Didn’t vote Erin Weir
For all you voted for this bill, there is a good chance you have never been out in the bush on the water.So here is my advice, on a early on spring or summer morning, get yourself a tims and go fishing. You can release the fish. Here is a thought if you don’t manage wild live who will